⭐ 4.7/5 from 12,000+ customers | 🚚 Free shipping over $49 | ↩️ Easy 60-day returns | 🧶 Soft Cotton Knits
What you'll find at Turtle Bay
Why Appleseed's shoppers feel at home at Turtle Bay
Appleseed's was the go-to catalog for women who wanted comfortable clothes that still looked put-together. When Appleseed's closed, that customer lost her store. Turtle Bay carries the same soft knits, same classic cardigans, same pull-on pants — and we ship from New York in 1–2 days.
Same Missy Fit
True-to-size S–3X, just like Appleseed's.
Same Soft Knits
100% cotton and cotton-rich jersey knits.
Same Classic Look
Button-front cardigans, modest necklines, timeless colors.
What Appleseed's customers order most from Turtle Bay
From former Appleseed's shoppers
Appleseed's shoppers ask
Add a Title Here to Introduce Your FAQ Section
No — we're an independent family-owned brand based in New York. We're not connected to Appleseed's, but our customers who shopped Appleseed's tell us our fit, fabrics, and classic styling are the closest match they've found.
Same classic styles. Same comfortable fit. New home for Appleseed's shoppers.